If your Medigap bill went up, you are not imagining a trend. KFF’s October 13, 2026 brief, using National Association of Insurance Commissioners data compiled through the end of 2025, found that the average Plan G premium among people who already have the policy rose from $171 to $194 a month between 2024 and 2025. KFF calls that a 13 percent increase. From 2020 to 2025, the same average rose 38 percent, from $140 to $194.
Those dollars are averages. They mix ages, ZIP codes, tobacco rates, household discounts, and high-deductible policies. They describe what current policyholders paid. They are not a quote for a new Plan G, and they are not the price in Idaho, Oregon, Texas, or Washington.
Plan G is the plan most people hold
Plan G was the most common Medigap policy in 2025. KFF says it covered 46 percent of policyholders, about 6.3 million people. For someone newly eligible for Medicare, KFF describes Plan G as the most comprehensive standardized policy still available: it helps pay the Part A deductible and the Part A and Part B costs that Original Medicare does not pay. It does not pay the Part B deductible.
Across every Medigap letter, the average premium among current policyholders was $244 a month in 2025. That all-policy average is higher than the Plan G average because it includes other letters, including Plan F, which has not been sold to people who turned 65 on or after January 1, 2020.
State averages for Plan G were wide. In KFF’s comparison of standardized plans, the 2025 average ran from $164 in New Mexico to $257 in New York. KFF also notes a $152 average in Wisconsin, and then sets it aside because Wisconsin uses different waiver plans rather than the same standardized Plan G. None of these figures is a price you can buy. Washington was one of the five states with the highest average Plan G premiums in that analysis.
Why the bill can rise even when your age does not
Medicare says each insurance company decides how to price its Medigap policies, and that the method changes what you pay now and later. Each policy uses one of three methods:
- Community-rated (also called no-age-rated). People pay the same premium regardless of age or gender. The premium is not based on your age. It can still go up because of inflation and other factors.
- Issue-age-rated (also called entry-age-rated). The premium is based on your age when you buy the policy. It is lower if you buy younger. It does not go up because you get older. It can still go up because of inflation and other factors.
- Attained-age-rated. The premium is based on your current age, so it goes up as you get older. It can also go up because of inflation and other factors. It may be the lowest price at the start and a higher price later.
Medicare’s examples of those three methods are illustrations. The dollar amounts in the guide are not real premiums.
States decide which of those methods a company may use. KFF lists nine states, including Idaho and Washington, that require community rating for policyholders age 65 and older. KFF also notes that Idaho has required community rating on new plans issued beginning March 1, 2022. Oregon and Texas are not on that required-community-rating list.
Read the increase letter with that in mind. The new amount comes from the insurance company, under the rating rules your state allows. A Social Security cost-of-living adjustment changes your Social Security payment. It does not set the Medigap premium, and it does not have to match the percentage on the notice.
When you can switch without health questions
After the first enrollment window, a Medigap company in most states can ask health questions and can say no. The main federal window is the six months that start when you are 65 or older and enrolled in Part B. During that window, a company cannot turn you down for health reasons or charge more because of a health condition.
Later on, a switch without health questions depends on a specific right, not on the fall Medicare Advantage enrollment period. Idaho and Oregon have birthday or anniversary windows for people who already have Medigap. Texas and Washington do not use that same rule. The dates, the plan letters you can move to, and who the window covers are in Medigap Birthday Rule: How Idaho and Oregon Let You Switch Without Health Questions.
If you are comparing the premium on your current policy with a different letter or a different company, ask whether that application will be underwritten. An average from a national study will not answer that, and it will not tell you the rate you would be offered.
Bring the notice, not the headline
We can read the increase against the way your policy is priced and tell you whether a birthday window or another guaranteed-issue right applies where you live.
Sources
- KFF — Key facts about Medigap enrollment and premiums for Medicare beneficiaries (October 13, 2026). Premiums and enrollment shares use National Association of Insurance Commissioners data compiled by Mark Farrah Associates through the end of 2025. Plan G averages are what current policyholders paid, not a new-enrollee quote. The Idaho community-rating date is in KFF’s state premium table note: new plans issued beginning March 1, 2022.
- Medicare — Choosing a Medigap Policy (official guide). The community-rated, issue-age-rated, and attained-age-rated descriptions are from the section “How do insurance companies set prices for Medigap policies?” Medicare says the sample premiums in that section are not actual costs.